Log In
Challenge-banner Challenge-banner-mobile

Stand Up for Superior Calf Growth

Stand Up for Superior Calf Growth

When it comes to developing muscular calves, the debate between standing and seated calf raises has always been a topic of interest among fitness enthusiasts.

Hypothetical question: If you could only pick one calf exercise, would it be standing calf raises or seated calf raises?

Groundbreaking new research from Japan provides compelling evidence on why the standing version may be the better of the two choices to maximize calf muscle growth.

Unpacking the Calf-Training Research

A recent Japanese study entailed a unique experiment where young men engaged in a 12-week training regimen performing calf raises. Each participant used one leg for standing calf raises and the other for seated calf raises, with both exercises periodized throughout the training protocol. The results were eye-opening: the calf muscle trained with standing calf raises exhibited more than double the growth compared to its counterpart engaged in seated calf raises.

The explanation behind this marked difference lies in the anatomy and biomechanics of the calf muscles. The calf is primarily composed of two muscles: the gastrocnemius (or "gastroc"), which is the larger, heart-shaped muscle visible on the back of the lower leg; and the soleus, which is situated deeper and often visible on the side of the lower leg.

Biomechanical Insights

The gastroc spans across both the ankle and knee joints. This positioning means that when your knee is bent at a 90-degree angle, as it is during seated calf raises, there is less tension on the gastroc, reducing its activation. Consequently, seated calf raises primarily target the soleus muscle. However, the study indicated that even the growth in the soleus from seated calf raises was not significantly greater than what was observed with standing calf raises.

On the other hand, standing calf raises require your legs to be straight, placing optimal tension on the gastroc, significantly enhancing its activation and subsequent growth. The study found that this exercise not only significantly increased the size of the gastroc, but it also had a meaningful impact on the medial and lateral aspects of this muscle.

Practical Application for Your Calf Training

So, what does this mean for your calf training routine? The evidence suggests that if you're pressed for time or looking to get the most bang for your buck from your calf workouts, your focus should predominantly be on standing calf raises. These exercises provide a comprehensive workout that targets both major muscles of the calves effectively.

However, it's important to note that seated calf raises still have their place. They can be a valuable addition to the end of your calf workout, helping to ensure a thorough training of the soleus muscle, even though the growth difference isn't as significant.

Long story short, while seated calf raises shouldn't be completely abandoned, standing calf raises are clearly the frontrunner when it comes to promoting maximal calf muscle growth. By integrating more standing calf raises into your routine, you're setting the stage for stronger, more developed calves that not only perform better but also look great.

Build stronger legs with a complete plan

Dr. Jim's programs lay out every leg exercise, set and rep, so you can put this into a complete plan.

Get My Program

References

Kinoshita, M., et al. Triceps surae muscle hypertrophy is greater after standing versus seated calf-raise training. Frontiers in Physiology, 2024.

 


Related Articles