HIIT vs Steady-State Cardio
Save time, burn more fat. Here are five reasons to skip the long, boring cardio in favor of high-intensity intervals.
Save time, burn more fat. Here are five reasons to skip the long, boring cardio in favor of high-intensity intervals.
Are you tired of doing endless, boring cardio workouts? Then stop doing it! Not only will the cardio boredom go away, but if you do HIIT instead, your results will improve, too.
For many years, the fitness community favored low- to moderate-intensity steady-state cardio, such as brisk walking or moderate-paced cycling, for what was believed to be its muscle-sparing and fat-burning benefits. Pretty much every bodybuilder and female fitness competitor I talked to 15 to 20 years ago had the same cardio routine: 45-60 minutes walking on a treadmill at 3-4 MPH. Many of them would do this twice a day — very time-consuming!
The rationale was that higher-intensity cardio would lead to muscle breakdown and that lower-intensity exercises put the body in an optimal fat-burning zone. However, modern research debunks these myths, highlighting the numerous benefits of high-intensity interval training (HIIT) over steady-state cardio.
So, should you swear off low-intensity walks, hikes, and bike rides altogether? Absolutely not. Being active is always a good thing, especially when you can do it outdoors. Do all the walking, hiking, and cycling you want. But to maximize your fat loss, fitness, and performance results, HIIT cardio should be a regular part of your routine as well.
Here are 5 good reasons to choose HIIT over steady-state cardio:
While lower-intensity cardio burns a higher percentage of calories from fat, it’s less efficient overall compared to HIIT. Steady-state cardio requires much longer durations to burn the same amount of calories as a shorter HIIT session. Moreover, the concept of the "fat-burning zone" is misleading. The real benefit of cardio for fat loss lies in the calories burned after the workout, known as excess post-exercise oxygen consumption (EPOC).
HIIT significantly enhances EPOC, leading to greater calorie burn post-exercise compared to steady-state cardio. This increase in metabolism after a HIIT session means that the body continues to burn calories, predominantly from fat, during the recovery phase. Research supports this, showing that individuals who perform HIIT burn more calories in the 24 hours following their workout than those who engage in steady-state cardio.
Contrary to the old belief, high-intensity cardio does not "burn up" muscle tissue more than low-intensity cardio. In fact, evidence shows that HIIT may help with muscle growth. Consider the physiques of long-distance runners versus sprinters: sprinters, who train with higher intensity, generally have more muscle mass than long-distance runners, who train at lower intensities for extended periods.
This muscle-sparing and muscle-building effect of HIIT can be attributed to the nature of the workout. HIIT involves short bursts of high-intensity activity followed by rest or low-intensity periods. This mimics the stimulus provided by weight training, which is known to build muscle. On the other hand, steady-state cardio primarily trains muscle fibers for endurance, potentially leading to smaller, less powerful muscles due to their increased aerobic capacity.
One more muscle-related factor to consider: Long-duration cardio has been associated with reduced testosterone levels in men, which can negatively affect muscle maintenance and overall health.
HIIT has been shown to enhance the metabolic machinery in muscle cells, promoting fat oxidation and reducing fat production. Studies demonstrate that HIIT increases the number of mitochondria in muscle cells, the organelles responsible for burning fat for energy. Additionally, HIIT improves insulin sensitivity, which helps in maintaining lean muscle mass and preventing fat storage.
Those hour-long steady workouts are not only boring — they’re also hard to fit into your day when you have work, family, and other obligations. Time efficiency is a significant advantage of HIIT. For those with busy schedules, a 15-minute HIIT session can yield better fat-loss results than an hour of steady-state cardio.
Beyond physical benefits, HIIT also enhances cognitive function . A study published in the Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research found that participants who performed a 20-minute HIIT session showed a 12% improvement in reaction time and a 10% increase in brain processing speed compared to those who rested quietly. This can be particularly beneficial for athletes in sports requiring quick decision-making.
While steady-state cardio remains a viable option, especially for those who enjoy activities like jogging or cycling, incorporating HIIT into a fitness regimen offers superior benefits in terms of fat loss, muscle maintenance, metabolic health, and cognitive function. By integrating a few days of HIIT into your weekly routine, you can enhance both your physique and overall performance.
To get started with HIIT, aim for a 2:1 ratio of high-intensity to low-intensity intervals, such as 30 seconds of sprinting followed by 15 seconds of walking. Gradually increase the intensity and duration as your fitness improves. Do HIIT workouts 2-3 times per week at first, progressing to 4-5 days a week as you get into better shape.
If designing your own HIIT workouts sounds daunting, don’t worry — HIIT cardio is programmed into most of my workouts here on JimStoppani.com, particularly my fat loss programs via techniques like cardioacceleration , Tabatas , and Power HIIT .
Dr. Jim's programs pair every workout with a meal plan, so you know exactly how to train and eat to get lean.
Get My ProgramRelated Articles