Free Weights vs. Machines: What Really Builds More Muscle?
Don't just stick to free weights—study shows machines build just as much muscle.
Don't just stick to free weights—study shows machines build just as much muscle.
You’ve probably heard it countless times from gym bros: "Free weights are better for building muscle than machines."
Not so fast! A recent study from Norwegian researchers provides some solid evidence that challenges this conventional wisdom.
The researchers examined the effects on muscle hypertrophy (growth), muscle strength, and even jump performance—whether you’re a novice or an experienced lifter.
The results? No significant differences were found between those training with free weights and those training with weight machines. In other words, using the chest fly machine can build just as much muscle as performing dumbbell flies.
This study sets the record straight: you can build muscle and strength effectively with either free weights or machines.
So, the next time someone at the gym insists that free weights are superior, you can point them to this study and let the science do the talking.
While free weights and machines can deliver similar results, I’ve always advocated for a combination of both in your training regimen. This approach not only maximizes muscle growth and strength but also reduces the risk of overuse injuries by varying the types of stress placed on your muscles. Interestingly, this recommendation aligns with the authors’ conclusions in the study.
So, whether you’re lifting free weights or using machines, remember: it’s not about which one is better—it’s about how you use them together to achieve your goals.
Dr. Jim's programs already put this research into practice, with every workout, set and rep laid out for you.
Get My ProgramHaugen, M.E., et al. Effect of free-weight vs machine-based strength training on maximal strength, hypertrophy, and jump performance - a systematic review and meta-analysis. BMC Sports Science, Medicine and Rehabilitation 15:103, 2023.
Related Articles